|
|
|
|
Think Globally, Act Locally
What You Can Do to Keep Industry and Jobs in Illinois
|
On October 15, 2003, at a manufacturing plant in Rockford, Governor
Blagojevich publicly announced that Illinois had been divided into ten "economic
development" regions. This change represents a shift from a centralized
business retention approach (Springfield and downtown Chicago) to a placebased
approach that more regularly incorporates feedback from local business
owners, labor leaders, government officials and community organizations.
The overall initiative is called Opportunity Returns, a comprehensive plan to bring
new jobs and increased stability to communities throughout Illinois. As more jobs
become outsourced to other countries and small plants close their doors, new
strategies should be launched in the context of a global society.
This point was reinforced in a
recent article on globalization posted on the MCIC
website, www.mcic.org. MCIC president, D. Garth Taylor, writes that each
business, unit of government, and non-profit organization concerned with living
wage jobs and quality of life needs to re-think its interests and programs in light
of the ever-evolving impacts of globalization.
The Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity (DCEO), the
lead agency charged with economic development initiatives in Illinois, decided to
do just that. It hired MCIC to assess past studies and literature, conduct key
informant interviews, and analyze secondary data on business retention patterns.
What will keep businesses in Illinois? How can we help businesses grow and
provide living wages and benefits for their employees? What sectors offer solid
opportunities for new business startups? What business retention and expansion
strategies are most effective? DCEO contracted with MCIC to help answer these
questions and to identify best practices and techniques that would help local
economic development agencies increase their effectiveness. Here we provide
just a few suggestions on what we can all do to make the Illinois economy
stronger and more competitive.
First of all, community residents, block clubs, social service organizations, health
clinics namely everyone can support local economic development agencies
and their programs at some level. The first three suggestions below refer to steps
we can all take. The remainder of the action items are mostly carried out by
government agencies and economic development groups. However, it is helpful
to see the big picture, even if we are not directly involved, so that we can identify
ways to support effective policies and partnerships.
-
Buy locally. Do your best to buy products locally and to identify other ways to
support your business community.
-
Ask some basic questions. What industries have done well in your community?
Which ones have done poorly? Why? Define sector and sub-sector priorities and
related strategies. A focus on firms that are viable and growing will provide
meaningful jobs and will support a diversified economy. No matter what you do
professionally, learning about your local economy is important.
-
Get involved. Are you a retired professional that could volunteer to administer
business retention surveys, or provide pro bono business advice? Does your
social service organization provide a free service or program that might be
suitable for the employees of businesses in your area? For example, non-profits
and banks have teamed to provide financial literacy training and information
about free checking accounts at the workplace. This has helped many
employees learn new skills and make better financial decisions. In turn, this also
makes them better employees. Be creative in identifying win-win partnership
opportunities.
-
Foster areas of collaboration and information sharing among Illinois towns,
counties, regions, and among neighboring states to minimize unproductive
bidding wars and the overpaying of firm location decisions. For example, if you
represent a chamber of commerce, work with other chambers to share
information and insights. There are many roles to play and a wide range of
contributions that groups in your area can make. Global dynamics means that
we can't operate in vacuums.
-
Use scarce resources effectively. We all become concerned when a local plant
threatens to ship jobs overseas or there is an opportunity to recruit a new
employer. In response, we scramble to identify what can be done to positively
influence those decisions. Emotional, political, and economic stakes become
heightened. But if we "over pay" for a location decision, we are, in essence,
taking funds away from more strategic investments in the local and regional
economy. We must use incentives and staff resources wisely. Locally developed
guidelines can help in this regard.
-
Help ensure that adequate facilities, roads, land, and communication
capabilities are provided for firms. Develop measures to identify and track the
most strategic infrastructure investments. Resources should flow to the areas
with the greatest potential for positive impacts. Help decision-makers say "no" or
"maybe later" to requests that would result in lower public and business benefits.
We all need to remember that these are long-term capital investments that
benefit more than one specific firm, stakeholder group, or town.
-
Use proactive, not reactive, methods. Local economic developers who
undertake reactive practices wait until a problem occurs or are alerted to a
situation by a particular firm or members of the community. Reactive modes
often produce short-term thinking and knee-jerk reactions that result in immediate
gratification, but long-term losses. If you ask business support groups which
style they adhere to, most would self-subscribe as "proactive." A review of their
practices, however, suggests that most are actually reactive in nature,
responding to "problems" and "political pressures." Clearly, there is an
opportunity for all of us to become more proactive, to understand and listen to the
needs of local firms, and to develop new methods of communicating with and
supporting and strengthening business networks.
-
Maintain positive relationships, trust, and credibility. After identifying and
addressing genuine market forces, successful business retention relies on three
key points: strong and positive relationships, trust, and credibility. The
successful business retention staff we talked to attend trade shows. They
maintain business directories. Marketing campaigns have been launched and
the Internet has proven to be a valuable tool. However, the most important factor
cited by nearly everyone we talked to was personal relationships between
business owners or plant managers and local community officials. It is important
to be in a position to anticipate business needs and help meet them. It is
important to make repeat visits to the same plant to maintain the relationship.
Know who is making decisions about operations and investments at the company
and have access to that person.
-
Inventory, evaluate, modify and publicize available educational and handson
training programs that enable workers to master the new skills required by
technological innovations.
-
Evaluate local business retention programs. Develop a system of clear
accountability and success measures, and support those programs that bring the
greatest long-term economic benefits.
-
Advance economic diversity, innovation, and the ability to adapt to, and
manage, change, particularly among high-tech sectors and knowledge economy
sectors. Nimble networks are needed and should be fostered and, as distance
matters less, we should expect that many networks will expand beyond state
boundaries to other states and regions and, indeed, the world.
All of us can do our part to advance Illinois competitive advantage in the global
economy. For more information on DCEO's programs and services, visit
www.illinoisbiz.biz
MCIC (Metro Chicago Information Center)
17 N. State Street, Suite 1600
Chicago, IL 60602-3294
T: 312.580.2878 F: 312.580.2879
info@mcic.org
|